Darth Venal said:
Thanks for the welcome!

I'll probably keep any unenthusiastic comments to myself, because no matter how well-intended they are, you always get attacked for them. So I'll just be a background member, if that's okay. I've never been a fan of forums and rarely sign up, but this one is particularly interesting to me, as I've been doing some "revision" work myself.

Can anyone tell me the easiest way to post it? I'd love to hear what you guys think.

DV

I assure you it clearly isn't the case, all through the process of both ANH:R and ESB:R (not to mention all the other edits on these boards) people have spoken freely about what they like and didn't like about them.

But people who post arrogant or idle boasts, unsubstantiated claims and/or comments which are counter to the observable truth get the sharp end of many keen minds (you know like in the real world) ;-)

Both yourself and Mr Ghostface joined pretty much around the same time and you have had nothing but a warm welcome because you have been politely inquisitive.

Mr Ghostface came onto the boards and at first made observations both positive and negative about this project and was welcomed much the same way as you were.

When he claimed that this edit was nothing special and easy to do and that people who praise it did so out of ignorance, then the mood turned.

Anyone who has followed this thread knows that none of those things are true.

Express yourself fully but if you feel the urge to tell someone that years of hard work aren't anything special and the same results can be achieved without the effort you'd better be prepared to back that up with proof or perhaps you should hold off.