dark_jedi said:
All I can say is WOW!

I have seen ALOT of fanedits,and this is just terrible,I cannot watch it at all,but if I send you the CD that I burned it on can you autograph it?

Ripplin is it true that you do indeed have a waaaay better version that is watchable? or is he blowing smoke up our collective arses?

In all serious though to you Ripplin,I cannot believe you uploaded that,you should have been able to see how bad that was from the start,work print or not,that is NO way to preview a new fanedit.

By the way,what do the folks at FE think about it,that should get very interesting over there.

Come on, be fair, sure even as a work copy it would have been a bit more sensible to up the picture quality a tad but it is just a work copy, it can be followed, you can see were the edit points are and access it to the point where constructive suggestions can be made.

I agree offering to autograph copies and all that jazz was an unfortunate display of peacockiness but A-M never said that this current incarnation was meant to be a DVD quality finished product, it's a rough illustration of a work in progress.

One benefit of the low quality was that for a cut that runs in at 4hrs it sure came down fast (even with my crappy connection speed) and it's rather brave to stick the whole thing as it currently stands out to be turned over for inspection (most editors just post the odd scene here and there at this stage).

Ripplin helped out a fellow board user and he should be applauded for doing that, what I love about this place is that people do go out of their way to help people out.

Now if this was put up as the finished product I'd be just as miffed, especially with all the earlier comments but it's clearly marked Work Copy and I can see enough to make comments and suggestions and that's what A-M posted it for.