brash_stryker said:
The changes I think need to be made:

Omit the name Skywalker

I'm so so on this. If a way can be found to keep it, and still have it make sense, I'd prefer that option. If not, then so be it.

Cut Anakin's whininess/slimyness and generally being an asshole. Existing edits have already proved this is possible

Definitely.

Make his turn more gradual and make it a seduction rather than a calculated decision. The way it is now is just awful.

Agreed.

No Vader in armour. The last we see of Anakin is being defeated on Mustafar.

I've thought a lot about this one. I'd love to see if the footage of Vader's construction can somehow be included in RotJ in flashback form. I plan on making my own mock-up of how this could work in the near future, when I get some spare time that is.

EDIT:
Does anyone know of any similar mock-ups that have already been, and if so where to find them?

Never have Padme tell Anakin about the baby. Never have the babies named and never see where they end up.

Probably for the best. It would be great if someone could, through some FX genius-ness, make Padmé not look pregnant?

EDIT:
Ah crap! I keep forgetting that the biggest problems with this entire concept are the issue of why Obi-Wan is watching over Luke, and the whole "A young Jedi...who was a pupil of mine...betrayed and murdered your father" fiasco.