Just watched and rated your clip SSWR. I really enjoyed it.

I don't like it when a scene is just getting established and then all of a sudden I, the audience member, get whisked away to another scene without warning. This is a problem I particularly had while watching The Phantom Edit. In this particular case I'm referring to the scene where Padmé is talking to Anakin while packing. I realize that there may not be much that can be done with it considering the amount of awful dialogue it contains, but I'd prefer to see it taken out completely rather than feeling like it's only half a scene. Still though, this is a fan edit, and if it can't be done then so be it. What matters is that the story is being serviced as best as possible.

Also, I am eager to see how those scenes with spliced footage look after their finished. It reminds me of how Adywan was able to add that extra clip of Wedge in ANH: Revisited by combining two different shots of his face, only this is a much more ambitious task. I particularly enjoyed the idea of Anakin playing with the trinket in the council chambers because it shows us that, for all his insistence that he is mature and capable, he really isn't.