logo Sign In

Post #367733

Author
C3PX
Parent topic
The Thread for CGi haters list movies you think were ruined by too much use of cgi. Not enough old school stuff
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/367733/action/topic#367733
Date created
30-Jun-2009, 12:35 AM
ChainsawAsh said:
Janskeet said:

Skyjedi2005, you're kind of becoming a broken record

Becoming?  I don't remember him ever talking about anything else for the past four years.  You get used to it, though - I'm at the point now where I can very quickly skim his posts to see if there's anything new in them, so it doesn't really bother me.

 

Ouch! Looks like Skyjedi just lost his biggest fan! I think it was just yesterday I read Janskeet's post where he defended him, and now I read this. How quickly they turn on you, eh Sky? Fans can be so fickle. Just ask George Lucas.

 

Janskeet said:
skyjedi2005 said:

I will admit i own multiple versions of the prequels on vhs tape, laserdisc, vcd,  and dvd but i never have watched them even once. 

Even TPM? I recall in one of your posts saying "it was not the greatest movie, but looked great on film."

 

There is no contradiction here. I also think TPM looked far superior visually from the later two films, but this doesn't mean I have had to watch it on home video (which I have done) in order to be able to say this. A single theatrical viewing is all it would really take. Hell, even just watching a few scene from a fanedit could lead you to the conclusion that TPM looks far better than the other two.