Well look at it this way, It is an idea. An idea does not mean that all fan edits will have that idea set in stone. Like Ady is going to kill Lando in ROTJ:R alot of people were against the idea including myself but after all it is Ady's re-imagining of the star wars saga and nothing we say is going to change it. A fan edit is usually what the fan editor wants. I for one don't have the time to make a fan edit so I am sticking to suggestions. Any suggestion is encouraged. Who knows what the ships will look like in Adywan's edit? Whatever he decides to do I will respect his decision because he and all fan editors take the time out of their busy lives to work on projects of such scale. I have attempted a fan edit but I do not have the patience and the tenacity for such work, so I scrapped all work LOL. Maybe somebody will see one of these suggestions and decide "Hey that is a good idea, I might try that." But don't take a suggestion as written law for all fan edits. Plus this is 'The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread', so no idea is a bad idea.