logo Sign In

Post #365900

Author
oh_riginal
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/365900/action/topic#365900
Date created
18-Jun-2009, 3:04 AM
ImperialFighter said:

or_iginal, it only took a few moments before the Falcon's full engine 'glow' appeared in that SE addition in 'ANH', as it rose upwards.  We saw the rear 'detail' for a short time, but overall it was fully 'glowing' pretty quickly after lifting off.

As far as the 'platform' take-off, there was plenty of time for it to have been fully 'aglow' from when Chewie sits down to charge up the engines (C3PO gets dragged by R2, and then we see Stormtroopers firing in-between times), to when we see it lift off the platform.  Also, it's almost facing us as we first see it turn around as it takes off from the platform, so this all makes it consistent with being fully 'aglow' by the time we see the rear of it. 

The sound effect just seems to tie-in with when the Falcon zooms off straight ahead, after it has lifted up and fully turned.  Although the engines are already fully 'aglow' at this point, it works fine for me I have to say.  I think you could be right about that sound effect in the trailer not being audible in the official release, perhaps due to the crescendo of the music at this point.

But when you watch the shot of the Falcon taking off from Docking Bay 94, the glow doesn't go full until you hear the engine roar at full strength.

Your point wouldn't be an issue for me, but when Ady added the sound effect to the Cloud City shot (I just checked the DVD version of this shot and compared it to the ESB:R trailer version and indeed the sound effect was not present before, at least not where Ady placed it), now it just seems natural to let the engine go full blue on cue with the engine roar, rather than be full blue the entire time.

Also, I think where Ady placed that sound cue is perfect, as all the Falcon does is lift up and turn around, THEN boosts off, which makes the new engine roar placement logical. Now all that is needed (just my opinion) is for the engine glow to match the sound of the liftoff.