rcb said:
adywan said:

Not everything needs to be explained in movies. like i said before we don't need to see Luke travelling down the shaft. If everything was explained to the audience then what's left for their imagination? Maybe we could get a cameo of Ric Olie in this scene working in the vane and explain everything to the audience?. lol

Finally! that's wat i try to tell people when they question a movie they see because they don't understand how it worked. Not everything in a movie needs to be explained people!

we're arguing over a weather vane! Wow! we should argue whether the AT-AT's lasers should be green or red.

Already done that... and the asteroid fart... and the blue vs. grey TIEs... and... is there anything else left? I think other than Ady posting an update or 2 every so often, this thread is getting needlessly filled up.

The weather vane/ vent pod/ whatever the thing is called debate happened about 4 months ago (more or less) with lots of pics from Vaderios, myself and others. I frankly would just leave the shot alone, and that way we can all imagine the carbon chamber where we would like it to be. I just don't want to see the pod changed to the point where it looks goofy and takes me out of the movie - because in order for the carbon chamber to fit in the top of the fin, that sphere is gonna have to be about 3 to 4 times bigger (considering the set is roughly 40 to 50 feet wide, with another 10 to 20 feet around it to account for the blue fog and the need for a gantry for Leia and Co to walk on to it. Compare a roughly 60 to 80 foot sized set to the 12 to 15 foot wide pod during the "Vader attacks Luke after he falls out the pod window" scene)

Because ye carbon of freezing chamber can only be in one of three places:

here:

here:

or here (yes, I know this is ruled out, but just putting it out to show the concept):

Regardless, I will patiently await to see what Ady has in store.