ImperialFighter said:bigbaddaddyvader said:Janskeet said:This set always baffeled me I made a post about this awhile ago and some of you guys blew it off calling it pure nonsense. Now look, you are bringing this up after blowing me off. So this wing that comes out into the middle of the shaft, is the carbon freezing chamber inside of it?
That would not make any sense to me were that to be the carbon chamber.With the movement of the duel and the size of the chamber and where Luke falls out the window I would have thought that structure would have needed to have been much larger.
If it's in a book though.....
Perspective be damned,lol.
bigbaddaddyvader, some here (myself included) thought that the 'Carbon Chamber' was meant to be situated somewhere in the 'surrounding' structure, and that Luke (and Vader) had travelled along the extending 'arm' leading to the interior of the 'vane'....rather than the 'Carbon Chamber' being somehow situated inside the 'vane itself near the top.... Having said that, I would have liked to see the extending 'arm' moved up a bit on the 'vane', so that it was more in line with the 'round window', to match the area that Luke is seen entering into as the 'gate' shuts behind him.
However, it seems that Adywan prefers to imply that the 'Carbon Chamber' IS at the top of the 'vane', and is probably one of the reasons that he is planning a miniature of this. I guess some of it's dimensions will differ quite a bit from the 'vane' currently seen, so this can seem more plausible.
I do understand that and for where Luke falls through the window it makes some sense however when Luke arrives at Cloud City and enters the door where R2 gets left behind he is clearly inside the main Cloud City structure as you can see the corridors,etc and then he goes up one little lift and hey presto he's in the carbon chamber.That to me doesn't make sense that he can go from the interior of the city to the wind vane structure like that especially seeing as the vane structure is so isolated in the mining shaft
But then again there really is no need to look TOO deeply into this!Doubtless Ady has his idea for this all mapped out anyway.