I can see both sides of this argument. Eyeshotfirst; I would agree with Asteroid-Man that the quality of what you've submitted isn't exactly something to get excited about. It lacks polish. And whilst I'm far from being a photoshop guru myself, I wouldn't have submitted something to a forum until it was of a reasonable standard.
Asteroid-Man, I do however agree that you have been a bit harsh in your posts, and have come across as a bit of a snob.