logo Sign In

Post #363329

Author
C3PX
Parent topic
So i used to like Star Trek V when i was younger and now i find it almost unwatchable it is so bad.
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/363329/action/topic#363329
Date created
3-Jun-2009, 12:35 PM
ChainsawAsh said:

The only purpose of the film is to retcon the changes The Wrath of Khan made (Kirk's son, the Genesis planet/device, Spock's death), the most offensive of which is resurrecting Spock.  That action cheapens his sacrifice in WoK immensely - the producers should've had the balls to kill him and keep him dead.

Yeah, that is what has always bugged me about that film. Its whole existence is to negate a great part of the previous film. Ought to have just killed David off in the last film for the dramatic ending and called it good. I guess Trek wouldn't have been the same without Spock, but why even kill him off in the first place then? I made my peace with this annoyance long ago though. Until yesterday, I hadn't seen it in years, and was able to enjoy it a lot more than I ever remembered enjoying it in my adult life.