What is with the facepalming, Comp? Seems like just about everybody I have ever talked to about this subject places 2 and 6 at the top of their list, 1 and 5 at the very bottom, and 3 and 4 in the middle.

With the TNG crew films is it more of a mixed bag though, I rarely find people who agree on them. But with TOS era films, there is very rarely much disagreement. My personal favorite TNG film is Insurrection (also the very first DVD I ever purchased), though most people absolutely hate it. I'd like the rank First Contact as my second, because I really enjoyed it, but the dumb concept of the Borg Queen being introduced really makes that hard for me. I love the whole concept of the Borg, but the idea of a Borg Queen is really weak, completely changes the nature of the Borg, and really knocks their coolness factor down quite a lot. They obviously felt the need to stick with the trend of having a villian, but I wish they had given it a pass just this once.