logo Sign In

Post #362696

Author
skyjedi2005
Parent topic
How would you have done ROTJ?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/362696/action/topic#362696
Date created
31-May-2009, 1:26 PM

I was just pointing out how foolish it would be to remake return of the jedi to fit the prequels, when it should have been the other way around the prequels should have been made to honor the original films and not change things and throw a wrench into continuity.

Lucas could have at least sat down in his screening room and rewatched them and taken some notes.  If he could'nt be bothered to then he could have had an employee do so.

Why would Luke visit the jedi temple on coruscant when neither existed when return of the jedi originally came out?  The name Coruscant created by Timothy Zahn and EU.  The Jedi temple another Lucas addition.  Which makes sense in the context of the story. 

I agree that Coruscant sounds better than Lucas own Had Abbadon for the Imperial Homeworld.  Well at least they did not call it Trantor and draw attention to stolen ideas from Isaac Asimov.

Again in my humble opinion making the lightsaber duel faster paced is Asteroid man wanting the original films to be more like the prequels. 

I for one am glad they are not.  Because i  prefer having 3  good films and 3 bad, in the case the older films were done to mesh with the prequels you have 6 bad films.