Well, I don't watch any of these shows. I've seen Lost once, and that was over a year ago. I honestly have a hard time wondering why either side is fighting over this. VINH (much easier to abbreviate than write full out... except that my explanation is even longer) thinks that the shows he think have gone to pot should be cancelled. Chainsaw and 3PX seem to think that if fans of the show are happy, then the show should be allowed to remain. I don't see what's wrong with either of these opinions, especially since they're just opinions and will have absolutely no bearing on whether or not any show is cancelled or renewed.
Here's my opinion: I wish shows like American Idol would be cancelled, despite the fact that millions of people apparently love it. I can't stand it and think it's representative of the mentality that gets shit renewed and good shows cancelled. I guess then that I'm falling on VINH's side since I want a show cancelled despite the fact that fans enjoy it. But then again, I don't exactly lose any sleep over its existence, and my opinion that I want it gone isn't going to make it so. I just don't like the show.
Then again, there are so many shows that were cancelled before they needed to be, and I wish I could have seen how they would have resolved themselves. Firefly is one of them. One of my favorite shows, so I don't appreciate the bashing toward it. ^_~
As for Bryan Fuller... I haven't seen many of his shows. I haven't seen Heroes, and I haven't seen Pushing Daisies. In fact, I've only seen one of his shows that I'm aware of, and it features Lee Pace pre-Pushing Daisies. I was just introduced to it two weeks ago, and I already got the DVD box set of it: Wonderfalls. Love it. It's amazing. I can't believe FOX cancelled it after only four episodes aired. Overall, I suppose I'd rather see shows given a chance to get better rather than be cancelled at a whim. That's how travesties happen like Firefly and Wonderfalls being cancelled. Yeah, FOX is stupid.