logo Sign In

Post #362462

Author
sketchrob
Parent topic
STAR WARS Descored/Rescored Yoda Vs. Sidious With New Score By Isaac Vail (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/362462/action/topic#362462
Date created
30-May-2009, 5:06 PM

No Angel they did not... as well as the opening credits... neither have dialogue or SFX, again I call upon logic to answer this question "Can you remove/separate dialogue, SFX, ambient noise and Music from a 5.1 mix?" the answer is no you cannot. You cant even guarantee a clean center channel, being that the mix will carry over into center channel sometimes (a fact I HATE mind you.. makes fan-editing a ton more difficult).

So, Fishmanlee, please do yourself a favor and post something of real substance/proof otherwise yur getting the hopes up of many editors dreaming of the idea of a clean mix to draw from. Personally, I think judging by the quality for your Poster for the "ReScore" I doubt your skillz, if not your judgement over a quality product... but thats just me, I may be wrong... lol right.