TheBoost said:
Akwat Kbrana said:
CG can be done right, but it must be approached with the aim in mind that it look real. The PT went instead for whacky cartoonisms, so its brand of CGI utterly fails to effectively "sell" itself to the viewer.

Nail on the head there.

I agree. The battle droids (aside from being damn annoying) looked pretty good in the prequels. It is the cgi creatures that aren't as convincing. I wonder if part of the problem is that the cgi characters are animated by different ILMers, so they don't develop their own 'personality'.

Having cgi look good as a remote object is one thing, having it be good as a living, that is something else.