Although I could not get a soul to help me out here (despite the number of copies of edits I've made for folks) :: grumble :: a friend came through and I finally had a chance to see these. Twilight of the Republic and The Black Knight Rises stood out for me the most. Incredibly well done, with some very intelligent cuts. The only edit that didn't work for me was cutting Shmi's death and Anakin's attack on the Sand People, as these are pivotal to his taking his first step toward the Dark Side. Otherwise, they were near perfect.