Tobar said:
Janskeet said:
I never liked this shot:

It's obvious that balcony used to be a closed wall because why would they leave an open entrance into cloud city from outside. Doesn't it rain on cloud city? PErhaps this could be changed to look more convincing.

I really wish you would at least try to look around a little before posting Janskeet. Right there in Ady's first post there's a side by side comparison of that shot.

I think Janskeet was saying that the altered scene (even in Ady's version) isn't as convincing as it could be because the wall on the other side of the balcony looks like an interior wall than an exterior wall (mostly because of the architecture which would be a real bugger to change).

Ady seems to be finished with what he is going to do with it but perhaps further colour alteration (it's a white polished wall so it might reflect the tinted light more) would add to the impression that this is an exterior shot rather than an interior one with a balcony painted on one wall).

Ady's floor and raised balcony does make the illusion more convincing than it was.