logo Sign In

Post #360297

Author
skyjedi2005
Parent topic
My Review of the Utah Symphony star wars trilogy cd versus the LP
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/360297/action/topic#360297
Date created
16-May-2009, 6:09 PM

Listening to the LP i am blown away by the increased dynamics.  The CD is a very nice release but the LP is audiophile quality.  The best part is the re-recorded return of the jedi stuff. Makes the CD special edition of the official set muddy in comparison.  This LP is a digital recording so its even better than the RSO LP.

Although i do prefer Williams over all.  The other orchestras timings are different sometimes.  Notes are accentuated differently for a concert hall performance rather than something scored for film.

I can only hope that someday Lucas sees fit to release a restored and uncut Return of the Jedi release from the original source tapes. 

I mean i have a CD conducted by Williams in the 1980's by the Boston Pops for the star wars trilogy and the dynamics on that CD are stunning in comparison to the official Lucas releases.  I might even track down the LP for reference purposes.

Then again i was listening to the anthology set CD box the other day and the music sounded much more alive than the special edition releases.  That and the LP's i have tell me that the Special editions are a frickin joke and only star wars was done right.  Empire reversed sound channels and missing cues.  Jedi so badly ruined by being a 3rd generation copy put through too much noise reduction.