Ah, see, therein lies the core of why we disagree. Note that I'm extrapolating from your post, if I'm wrong please tell me, but this is my understanding.
You (and many others) feel that fan edits, if made at all, should be made to fix mistakes and problems.
I (and many others) feel that fan edits should be made when someone dislikes something about a film, and they feel that they can improve upon it.
I'm sorry if you got the impression that I don't want to discuss things, but that's what I got from your post:
"People I can't believe you want to re-edit a perfect movie like TDK."
This statement implies that you are inherently against any change at all to said "perfect" movie, and I was just trying to get you to understand the reasoning behind said changes. Admittedly, I may have been a bit carried away, but your arguments against my points seemed, to me, to be little more than "Well, your complaint is unfounded because I can explain it!" I know there are explanations for these things, and I don't think they hold any water. That's all.
The reason I was so stand-offish in my arguments was that it seemed to me like you were simply trying to convince people not to edit TDK at all, which I feel is pointless since A) it's already been done and B) it will be done again.
And with fan edits, EVERYTHING is about opinion and personal taste. That's why there are so many different fan edits. If you disagree with something in a fan edit that's being discussed here, bringing it up is good and brings about healty discussion. But when someone is trying to argue against the very existence of an edit, as I felt you were, the entire discussion is pointless since that person's never going to convince the editor not to edit it and the editor will never be able to convince that person that editing this particular film isn't somehow sacriligeous.
I apologize for coming across as being rude. That wasn't my intention. I posted my last comment after getting into a heated argument with my jackass roommate, so some of that anger bled over into my post. Sorry about that.
Whaddaya say we agree to disagree? :-)