logo Sign In

Post #359764

Author
Jedi Dark Knight
Parent topic
Ideas Thread: for... The Dark Knight edits
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/359764/action/topic#359764
Date created
12-May-2009, 7:35 PM

1. "probably with lasers" what if it is something else, in my opinion it does sound plausible, if it doesn't to you then...is a matter of opinion. How the fingerprint reacts to the environment I think neither of us is qualified enough to say it can or can't, as I said it sounds plausible, but again, is a matter of opinion.

2. Don't like the eject-a-pod? nor the chase? ok...again, keyword: "like" I can't say anything about likes since they are as personal as things get.

3. The Voice changer it has been implied in the related material in the DVD that it is inside the cowl, lame explanation? maybe. HE does the change, probably. (in the comics HE does it so...whatever)

Why we are having this argument? because I saw things that *could* happen dismissed as pointless and dumb and impossible, but you have nailed the point home for me: if people make fan edit to fix mistakes is one thing and those mistakes can be reasoned, argued and discussed, if they want to for the sake of their own whim/like/dislike then there's no point in arguing since as I said above likes are personal, but then why have a forum to discuss your own tastes if in the end when a different opinion arises someone is just going to shoot the argument with "I like it this way" and finish it, the point of a forum is discuss things openly, if the point is show what you did out of "taste" then all post should just be "I like it" and "I don't" and nothing comes out of it. Again you hit the point home for me: hammering things that are "tastes" with reason IS dumb (the word you used is jerk) I though we were hammering things that were considered mistakes, hence be reasoned with.

I sense your post ends with something along the lines of "don't like it, don't download it" which again goes with what I said above: "what's the point of showing your *tastes*, you show reasons to fix mistakes, since those can be argued, tastes are tastes.

 

And I'm not attacking you man, easy. We are talking.