The Gene Roddenberry years, when stories might play with questions of science, ideals or philosophy, have been replaced by stories reduced to loud and colorful action. Like so many franchises, it’s more concerned with repeating a successful formula than going boldly where no “Star Trek” has gone before. - Roger Ebert on Star Trek 2009

http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090506/REVIEWS/905069997

Ebert’s history of reviews of TOS based Star Trek movies:

Movie 1.TMP: ***

Movie 2. TWOK: ***

Movie 3. TSFS: ***

Movie 4. TVH: ***1/2

Movie 5. TFF: **

Movie 6. TUC: ***

Movie 11. ST (2009) **1/2