logo Sign In

Post #358328

Author
Monroville
Parent topic
The Prequel Radical Redux Ideas Thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/358328/action/topic#358328
Date created
5-May-2009, 2:14 AM

Whew boy!

Vaderios: I like the alterations, buuut:

This is a great example of what is so wrong about the entire PT: long, drawn out shots and cruddy, infantile dialogue (and what is with the goofy flip?  Did Vader ever make an entrance like that?) that ultimately kills the drama of any scene or plot point.  While JEDI may not be the best of examples in general movie terms, compare the Luke/ Vader/ Emperor scene while the rebel/ imperial battle was happening outside to this scene.

Is there any way to edit this not so much to match any OT flavor, but just to emphasize a HUGE BATTLE is happening outside that could destroy the ship they are in, much less they are about to fight a Sith Lord/ Rogue Jedi Master (hmm, 2 on 1 again... man, those Jedi weren't very honorable, were they?  Also, why is it that the Jedi are the first to ignite their swords and attack?)? 

Or just to put it simply: to get rid of (or dub) the boringly spoken dialogue as well as some of the actual lines ("fighting Sith Lords is our specialty!) and just... make it serious enough to TAKE seriously?