Dr. M, I can't speak for everyone here, but I for one have no trouble differentiating between ID's overhaul and an edit more like my own. We all agree that several scenes need attention and having a dialog about those scene in one location on this board is actually helpful in my opinion. ID's free to make his own thread of course if he wants, but I don't understand your reasoning for it.
I don't plan on changing the entire structure of the film, but I'm open to it. There are lots of folks here who love the idea and who love ID's previous work on the Indy series. Work that shows to me a love and care for the series. Not a dislike exactly.
(not to mention that ID's presence here has boosted this thread which helps me on my edit...)
And seriously? LC over ROTLA? (jk)