TheBoost said:
It's odd to me how many people prefer "Sad Flautists" to "Yub Yub."

Without commenting on their musical worth, does that mean the Special Editions really aren't disliked philisophically. I mean, is it fine for Lucas to frak with his films, as long as we like the results?

I Greedo had ORIGINALLY shot first, would we say the SE was great if Lucas changed it to Han?

If it's "Curse you Lucas for changing these movies!" for things we don't like, shouldn't that same viewpoint apply to all of the SE changes, Jawas falling off of Rontos and the South American Pipe music?

As far as I'm concerned, any changes are not good, because they're not the original. But things that are not the original don't tend to fit with the films like the originals things do. Yub nub is true to the intended spirit of ROTJ's ending. The 97 music is not.