i found his reviews funny, a bt silly, but quite funny. i think he'd make a much better comedian than a critic.
the key problem with the prequels for me, that ironically was the only thing he didnt pick up on, was that it missed star wars' simple plotlines, that focus more on characters and ground level people than the 'big events' that seem to, in themselves be quite simple ideas. the PT was pretty much the reverse of this.
i must admit, the new clone wars series on the other hand, is much more star wars for me i find. anakin is more of the anakin i would have like to have seen in the movies, the clone troopers provide that ground level character to have a face, and the cartoonish simple plots are great.