logo Sign In

Post #353981

Author
Docta Nick
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/353981/action/topic#353981
Date created
11-Apr-2009, 12:40 PM
trimboNZ said:

I'm all in favour of keeping the end sequence of ESB pretty much as it is.

This scene is IMO about as close to a Binary Sunset moment that ESB gets, and the galaxy shot has become fairly iconic of the mood.  Change the visual too much, and the original mood is lost.  As for astronomic accuracy, we must remember Star Wars is Science Fantasy, not Science Fiction.  We don't need Star Trek style explanations for every technology and phenomenon, and that IMO is one of the great differences between the two universes.  Whether we're looking at a star formation, the local galaxy viewed from the outer edge (rim?), bright matter circling an occluded black hole or a nearby galaxy viewed through some lensing effect of interstellar dust it doesn't really matter.  Though I'll freely admit I am rather fond of the Rishi Maze explanation (I feel it ties in with AOTC rather well on a subtle level, and is still plenty big for a fleet to 'hide' in). 

If we do start down the dark path of fixing things that are implausible to current science, then even the Binary Sunset shot, where two nearby stars appear the same size and in close proximity from an orbiting planet, is in trouble.

 

 

Great point, i did always like the scene, i just think maybe the falcon should be looking like it's going IN the galaxy thing or whatever it is instead of just ranomly going off in a direction. Basically just minor changes r needed for the scene, which is the way it should be.