I love ANH:R and I have loved everything I have seen with ESB:R. To me Adywan has not let me down yet and if he wants to change the story at the end of ROTJ:R I say let the man work. Like other people have said, it is his edit and if you don't like it in the end, re-edit it yourself. I for one am very interested to see this version and I always have thought someone major on the good side had to die. ROTJ is too happy compared to the first two films and it shouldn't be. The EU doesn't exist to me, as I have always just viewed the films as Star Wars and thats it. Go on with your edit Adywan for I will consider that Star Wars. :)