Hmmm. Interesting concept. Techically speaking, the opening logo was a little long, and the dialogue is drowned out by the "new" music. Thematically speaking...no Star Wars music? I understand the effort, to consolidate the story into an epic, but really...removing the main theme? It's at a point where some fan edits are simply to modernize, reimagine and remove what makes Star Wars...Star Wars. Battlestar Galactica (the new one) was an awesome show, with a completely different atmosphere then Lucas' saga. Unless we pick up cameras and reshoot everything again, it's going to remain different. I don't want to crush anyone's creativity, but removing the trademark stuff like music just jumped out at me:) What will you do with the swing across the chasm? Good luck with the rest.