Did you even bother following the discussion before making that post?

Discussion about films comes down to whether you liked it or not. The rest is laying out your reasons for your preferance and trying to win others over to your preferance. That's pretty much all it comes down to.

What I was doing is trying to talk some sense into people who use the majority's opinion to form their own. It's a shoddy defense, and it constrains a fan from thinking for themselves. It's unfortunate.

I'd like to see Janskeet's response to the SHH poll before really delving into my reasons for not liking ROTJ.