STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW — Page 313

& then we will take them back out again LOL

a flash back is pointless when I have kids Im gonna show em the movies all in a row. A flash back in ROTJ is as pointless as the bring my shuttle to the star destroyer scene in ESB.

Sevb32 said:

Look everyone wanted their own imaginations to be the prequels. I guess that's what happens when you make parts 4-6 first and give people almost 20 years to think about it before you release part 1. There are thousands or even millions of "My way"s.

And that's exactly why we need to say the hell with PT:R once ROTJ:R is finished, and just reshoot the whole damn thing! :)

I think Ady's capabilities should be up to that point by the time it rolls around....

Thanks dumb_kid for the clarification! :)

We really need to get a round table discussion (with audio) going sometime.  Then any sarcasm, seriousness, etc., could be interpreted a bit better.  There's only so much that comes across in the printed word.  But that's not the point of the forum.

And don't get me wrong about the prequels, I quite enjoyed them the first time around (I even saw TPM something like 9 times in theaters).  The experience of anticipating and seeing them with my friends and family are memories I cherish.

As I've aged and digested them, however, the films and their weaknesses don't sit well anymore.  Which is why we have fan edits, I guess.  But there's only so much one can do with the source material.  Some edits I've seen are simply hideous, while others improve the overall experience (Uncanny Antman's T3 edit is very well done, for example).  I do wish for better films, but am accepting to a degree to what we have.  I do have faith Ady will come up with some fantastic edits of I-III.

Again, this is only my most humble opinion.  If you love the films, then by all means continue enjoying them.  I'm not trying to sour anyone's opinions of these movies.  We all have different tastes and that's what makes these discussions great and sometimes very heated.  I know I like some movies others despise.  "Surviving the Game" with Ice-T and Gary Busey?  I love that flick, but I'm sure most don't. ;)

Back to the matter at hand:

Ady, any chance of a live chat in the future, like what you did with ANH:R?  Maybe after the trailer is released?

Here are some PINK 5 clips:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IW11ly5Urts&feature=channel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jy8ZjhnijgM&feature=related

http://www.pinkfive.com/

Jeyl said:

Adywan hates EU and has stated that it does not exist for him. He'll accept the prequels any day over any EU material no matter how good they might be. 

Adywan doesn't hate the EU, he just isn't letting it constrain these edits. As well he shouldn't. In fact, GL didn't feel constrained by the EU when he wrote the prequels, leading to several cases of retcon.

The Pink Five films aren't EU canon, they're fanon. A character implied to be Stacey appears in an EU novel, that's as close as it gets to EU.

The Pink Five films aren't EU canon, they're fanon. A character implied to be Stacey appears in an EU novel, that's as close as it gets to EU.

I will continue this conv again to this thread. :)

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/The-Prequel-Radical-Redux-Ideas-Thread/post/352371/#post352371

-Angel

Monroville said:

Here are some PINK 5 clips:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IW11ly5Urts&feature=channel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jy8ZjhnijgM&feature=related

http://www.pinkfive.com/

Thanx for the links.

RoccondilRinon said:

Jeyl said:

Adywan hates EU and has stated that it does not exist for him. He'll accept the prequels any day over any EU material no matter how good they might be. 

Adywan doesn't hate the EU, he just isn't letting it constrain these edits. As well he shouldn't. In fact, GL didn't feel constrained by the EU when he wrote the prequels, leading to several cases of retcon.

Adywan has often said that EU is not in the scope of the things he will take into account

I'll admit, alot of EU is garbage, but for the sake of the good stuff, I hope Adywan doesn't kill off Lando and the Falcon or have Boba Fett dodge getting eaten by the Sarlacc Pit. Or anything too dramatic.

Enigmas said:

I'll admit, alot of EU is garbage, but for the sake of the good stuff, I hope Adywan doesn't kill off Lando and the Falcon or have Boba Fett dodge getting eaten by the Sarlacc Pit. Or anything too dramatic.

Damn kill Lando and damn that is a ESB:R thread :)

-Angel

vaderios said:

Enigmas said:

I'll admit, alot of EU is garbage, but for the sake of the good stuff, I hope Adywan doesn't kill off Lando and the Falcon or have Boba Fett dodge getting eaten by the Sarlacc Pit. Or anything too dramatic.

Damn kill Lando and damn thats a ESB:R thread :)

-Angel

 

 You mean a ROTJ:R thread :o

Josh said:

 You mean a ROTJ:R thread :o

Its Frustrating i can say :P

vaderios said:

Damn kill Lando and damn that is a ESB:R thread :)

-Angel

 

I don't understand.

But I get the gist, I guess. Back to ESB:R.

A chatbox? Why not an IRC channel?

-Angel

Dangerous Incorporated said:

Monroville said:

Here are some PINK 5 clips:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IW11ly5Urts&feature=channel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jy8ZjhnijgM&feature=related

http://www.pinkfive.com/

 

Thanx for the links.

No problemo.  And guys?  It's not a matter of INCLUDING the PINK 5 stuff into any of this, but just showing what they've done, as well as refer them to Ady in case he needs some technical help (especially when JEDI:R comes around).