CO said:
rcb said:
and the redone ending makes so much more sense then the original.

I have to take issue with that, because I think it doesn't make any sense.

If you are referring to a younger Anakin put in the ghost scene, that totally dispels the point of ROTJ. ROTJ is about the redemption of Darth Vader, and how the older Anakin, is conflicted thoughout the movie, and finally saves his son by killing the Emperor. By showing an older Anakin standing there next to an older ObiWan, you see the character come full circle, as his redemption is complete.

By changing the ending in the SE with Hayden in the ghost scene, Lucas says that Anakin died on Mustafar, which would totally contradict ROTJ since it was the OLDER Anakin who was conflicted, it was the older Anakin who killed the Emperor, and the OLDER Anakin who tells Luke, "Tell your sister you were right...."

By saying Anakin & Vader are two different people misses the point of ROTJ because they are ONE person the whole time, and even though he went by Darth Vader throughout the OT, there was always was that part of Anakin, the good guy that never left.

Even Lucas doesn't even understand the original story he wrote back in 1983, just so he could stick some gimmick in the 2004 DVD's and try to tie the trilogies together.

that part i don't care about, i just meant the celebration scenes on bespin,tatooine, naboo and coruscant. it gave the non EU fans a look at the aftermath for those planets.