logo Sign In

Post #347827

Author
Jeyl
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/347827/action/topic#347827
Date created
7-Mar-2009, 6:33 PM

(Watches the Escape from Hoth clip in anticipation)

Hmm.... Yes.......Yes.......

I like what you've done here Adywan. But I'm gona be the guy who points out everything so no one else has to.

Pros

- Very nice ion effect. Not too different to be noticeable and straight to the point just like the original. Also the addition of the first two ion shots was a good touch.

- Warping out. Nice touch!

Cons

- The activity. It's probably me, but the amount of activity in that one shot with the X-wing getting blown up and the added Star Destroyer lasers kind of throws the focus off from the Ion Bolts as they make way to the Star Destroyer. I personally think the shot is better without the X-wing blowing up since the 'triumphant' music piece fits more with the fact that they every craft made it out. It also makes for a good shift in tone when things are looking up at the start compared to what happens during the ground battle.

- The X-Wing warping out. I know you saw this coming, but that X-Wing looks very two dimensional compared to the very 3-dimensional transport. 

 

A good solid effort once again by Adywan. Keep them coming!