Vaderisnothayden said:
skyjedi2005 said:
Even if Revenge of the Sith is by far and large critically and received by fans of the prequels as the best of the 3 the acting is horrible. The Lightsaber duel was pretty awesome minus the rediculous riding over the lava on droids part, and was really trying to be a redo of duel of the fates from menace. But Haydens " You underestimate my power" was beyond bad acting. And then of course you have the Emperor and Yoda acting like they are in a loony tunes cartoon. And then Vader walking like Frankenstein and goin N000000000000000000!!!. Nearly as bad as Shia swinging with monkeys like Tarzan in indiana jones 4, or the flying in a nuked fridge,lol. Indiana had a nice three mile ride through the air and just gets up and dust himself off.

And then we have Anakin's ranting. When he rants about how from his point of view the Jedi are evil he looks like he's about to burst into tears like a little kid. When he screams "You underestimate my power!" the lameness factor is mind-boggling. And then later after he's been chopped up and fried he screams at Kenobi "I hate you!" like a little kid who's been denied a treat. I half expect to shout "If you don't say I won, I'll hold my breath until you do!" Between the script and the talents of Hayden Christensen the character of Darth Vader is totally rubbed in the shit in this scene.

Overall I think the scene is one big load of meaningless pompous overdone show and one of the worst scenes I've ever seen in any film ever.

The Emperor and Yoda fight was awful. Horrible overacting for the Emperor. Annoying CGI Yoda with his macho posing that's so totally inappropriate for the character. It was hard to decide which character was more annoying. I wanted to flush both of them down the toilet. And that was intercut with the Mustafar scene, for maximum lameness.

You guys don't like the PT?! And you don't like Hayden!!?! Or Indy 4!!? I had no idea!

I wonder if the topic of a thread was "Who Likes Birthday Cake" if you would respond with why you hate the PT.