Monroville, I've just realised that your recent 'additional Stardestroyers' suggestions (which tie-in nicely with the 'Fleet approaching Hoth' shot that appears just a little before), did not mention anything about this 'interior' shot, which has been confirmed as being the inside of Captain Lennox's 'Tyrant' Stardestroyer.
(It comes immediately after the 'single Stardestroyer over Hoth' shot, which I've always presumed is meant be the the exterior of the same ship - which would be the 'Tyrant')
However, Adywan has now confirmed he intends to add a 'couple' of extra Stardestroyers into the 'Fleet approaching Hoth' shot (so there'd now be 5 'standard' Stardestroyers' seen, if indeed 2 are added), and this throws up a few various possibilities for the view seen from the 'interior' SIDE-windows, depending on where the additional ships might be placed.... So in light of this, and your recent suggestions that I liked, here's one possible description of how this 'interior' shot could perhaps look now, which I prefer to any of my previous 'mock-up' suggestions for it, that I've posted in the past -
While I still believe the current shot showing the Hoth Planet element seen through the 'windows' is unfortunately very wrong , I now prefer the idea that this 'interior' would remain a SIDE-view on the LEFT-hand side of the 'Tyrant'. (The existing very slight 'forward motion' during the shot, certainly gives this impression)
The current 'Fleet approaching Hoth' shot shows the 'foremost' Stardestroyer (presumably the 'Tyrant') in the distance, to the right of the 'Executor' and the others....so perhaps by this point, we'd now see only the 'starfield' through the MIDDLE window, while through the LEFT window only , we'd see that Captain Lennox is looking out at a couple of the other 'standard' Stardestroyers there, that are approx. the same distance away on his LEFT-side, as is shown in the 'approach' shot (they would be seen 'side-onwards', coming into the LEFT window only, but might not necessarily include showing the 'Executor' which may have hung back a little), and there'd also be just a hint of the Hoth Planet's 'curve' showing now, that would be seen in a portion of the RIGHT window only , behind Captain Lennox's back (either at the very bottom , except reversed....OR placed at a DIFFERENTLY - positioned 'curve' further up in the RIGHT window, giving the impression the ships are pointed more at the middle of Hoth, rather than positioned 'over' it.... Personally, I can view the angle of the current 'single Stardestroyer over Hoth' shot as being either way!), to help indicate a little 'forward motion' towards it still, as the Planet moves a little more into the RIGHT window....
Anyway, just a final thought on that for completion's sake Monroville, and I'd be interested to hear your and other's (especially Adywan's of course!, although I won't expect to at this point) own preferred layout for the 'window' shot too....but I guess it's all dependant on whether the 'Tyrant' is still indicated to be the 'foremost' Stardestroyer by Adywan or not, which is dictated by where he places his extra additions.... However, if there were to be additional Stardestroyers shown in the actual 'single Stardestroyer over Hoth' shot itself, it could even be argued that the 'interior' shot was cutting to the inside of one of these new additional ones now, which is meant to represent the 'Tyrant' instead....if that's what Adywan wishes to imply with his new layout! (Ouch!, my head hurts again....)
At this point Adywan, I'd like go back to the 'Fleet approaching Hoth' shot that is shown in my previous post, and mention the 'Moons'/ blue 'Planet'? , that are seen in this shot shown below , that comes at the end of the AT-AT battle. (Note: just ignore the speculative Stardestroyer elements that were added to these next 2 shots at the time, at my request) If you look at the 'Fleet approaching Hoth' shot, you'll see there is either a 'Moon' or a 'Planet' behind the Hoth Planet. It seems quite WHITE in the SE, but is this meant to be the blue 'Moon' or 'Planet' in the distance, at the bottom of the frame in the shot below? Also, on the previous 'approach' shot shown above, we can see a definate little white 'dot' just above the front of the 'Executor's' front prow. It is there for the duration of the shot, and seems to indicate a 'Moon'.... If it's not meant to be that, then it would be better removed, as it is in front of the area of the Hoth Planet that is in shadow.... I'll let you be the final judge on these decisions, but the point I'd like to emphasise is this - Should there be any kind of hint of Hoth's 'Moons' / or neighbouring 'Planets'? added to any of the other Hoth Planet shots, from the different angles that we see, do you think? -
....and I'm just including this other view below too, for additional reference, so that all the Hoth Planet shots are nearby to scroll up and down.... (again, ignore the Stardestroyer element that was added at the time) -
By the way Monroville, although I've now come round to being quite happy to see the existing shot of the 'single Stardestroyer over Hoth' kept, if Adywan chooses to do so (especially with his better colouration)....I'm still going to show my 2 favourite ALTERNATIVE variations for the shot (which lasts approx. 2 seconds), that I'd happily see also, but with a couple of additional comments about some changes -
One is this 1st alternative version above, which would have the Stardestroyer moving along from the LEFT-hand side of the frame instead....
Considering all the potential 'Fleet' positioning ideas and possible additions previously mentioned, this gives a rough idea of how one or more other ships could be shown on the LEFT-hand side of the 'main' one seen in the foreground (currently implied as being the 'Tyrant')....
....OR there's this 2nd alternative version below, (which would use the final 2 seconds only), from the end of the 18-seconds long Stardestroyer element used in the 'intro.' shot from 'JEDI' instead....
Again, considering all the previous recent suggestions and descriptions, I'd probably remove the smaller, extra ship I previously speculated about adding to this shot, and would prefer the Hoth Planet element to be more centrally-located in the MIDDLE of the frame instead, so that it seems the 'Tyrant' is seen heading 'straight-on', directly towards it now.... Also, because of the 'downwards'-pointing angle of the Stardestroyer element, the whole Hoth Planet element itself could be moved DOWN in the frame a little, so that the prow is only 'intersecting' over a smaller portion of the top of it now. There could be a hint of a 'Moon' or distant 'Planet' somewhere around here too.... -
One last thing, if there's any kind member here that is willing to PM me a step-by-step guide on how I can 'reply with quote' SEVERAL comments from VARIOUS posts, all together into one SINGLE post that I might like to make in future, I'd appreciate it, lol. I still haven't figured out how I do this, and it would be a very helpful thing for me to know! Many thanks. :)