logo Sign In

Post #346572

Author
ChainsawAsh
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/346572/action/topic#346572
Date created
24-Feb-2009, 3:29 AM
gavin77 said:
Jeyl said:
gavin77 said:

Well I don't know if this is the reason, but in Star Wars The Clone Wars, which is completely Lucas' vision and direction, where the Ion Cannon is first introduced as a seperatist weapon, it is blue, with the energy/lightning thing going on. 

Yes, but the Clone Wars is EU territory just like the previous series. Both are done with Lucas' vision and direction and are do exactly the same thing. And if I may say add, the spinning star field is also a part of Lucas' vision and direction as well. 

- Jeyl

Way off topic, and not a big deal, but The old Clone Wars miniseries was EU, where George basicly just let it happen. No involvement. The new one, he is actually writing a lot of the material, and if an episode is written by someone else, it is written by them with a basic outline for the episode by George and Dave Filoni. George edits almost every episode, and the entire main story arc and direction is completely George. This is the story that George himself wanted to tell, that's why he's doing it. The live action series coming out that takes place between ep3 and 4 is also supposed to be his story, and not considered EU. I look at it almost like Empire, he wrote the general story, and someone else directed it and filled in the blanks. Take it for what it's worth. Peace....

 

It really depends on what you consider to be canon.  And if we're talking EU here, then the six movies are canon and everything else (any TV media or the Clone Wars movie included) is considered EU by definition.  Whether you consider all EU to be canon, or just some of it, or, for Ady's purposes, none of it at all, it's still EU.

And Ady has said he doesn't give two shits about anything EU for his "Revisited" edits, which is more than fine by me.