Quote
Originally posted by: Shimraa
Ok here I go again. Another PT OT arguement. Warbler first off, STARWARS IS NOT YOURS. You may enjoy it, you may feel that you have say in it cus you supported it but ill say it again. STARWARS IS NOT YOURS. If Gorge lucus wants to make it his way then there he does. It is his call how or how not to make the movies. Another thing GL is not a god, there is no way in my opinion that one guys can come out with 2 villians of the same caliber as Vader. Vader will go down in history as one of the greatest and most memoriable villians in cinema history. Next GL made the OT for himself you cannot say that he made it fro the fans because the fan did not exist at the time. No one knew the Starwars was going to become a big hit before it came outso you cant say that the OT was made for the fans. lastly i pose a question. What exactly in your opinion made the PT bad. You have to rember Before you answer that the OT dealt with one small charater on a few focused adventures, where as the PT deals with alot of characters on a galatic scale.
Ok first off Your right when you say that Lucas can make Stars Ways his way. However that does not mean I have to like it. Yes Star Wars is not mine but if it weren't for me and the rest of the fans there would be no Star Wars or least no sequels. The fans bought the tickets, toys, videos, books, clothes and other merchandise that made him his millions. And yea of course there were no Star Wars fan before Star Wars came I was really refering to movie fans in general. Stars Wars was made to entertain the viewer, The PT was made for Lucas to fullfill his dream.
As for why I think epIII is going to suck, as I said before lots of Jar,Jar Binks(stinks), bad acting, flat characters. poor plots, lots of CGI crap, a horrible script. Why do I believe the epIII will contain these things? Simply because ep 1 and 2 did and I believe that he will make epIII in the same style. Please note I am not the only one to criticize ep 1 and 2. Put yourselve in my shoes. If you thought that ep 1 and 2 sucked and could'nt hold a match much less a candle to the Ot, and you believed that epIII was going to be made in the same style as ep 1 and 2 would you or would not conclude that epIII will suck as well?
I hope I'm wrong but I doubt it and if I am I'll be glad to eat crow. If you liked ep 1 and 2 you will probably love ep3. Just understand that not everybody did and therefor they will probably not like ep3 as well.
P.S.
You say Lucas is not a God, I agree so tell me why you worship him like he is a god and why do you act like he can do no wrong and get angry at those who dare question his "great vision"?