WheresBlackhawk said:Sigh...it appears everyone's interest has waned.
I think the problem here is people seem to be running before they have even evolved lungs.
There are already some great ideas on here but it's sort of descended into concerned posts from people who don't like specific ideas or want to animate it in a specific way, when there isn't even enough put down to make one solid story (let alone three) and picking the animation style is something you do when you pretty much have a finished script (not before).
If people are serious about doing this sort of thing those that are should go read this thread from top to toe, pick the ideas they like, write a story treatment, see if any of the responses to it are useful and then press onto a full script.
Then cast the audio recording and resource sound effects etc and then set a house style that volunteers can work to so if people drop out of the project other people can pick it up without changing the look and the thing can get finished.
This thread should be stage one (pulling for ideas).
Stage two should be picking the story treatment (there could be more than one project).
Stage three polishing various scripts and tightening every bolt and pre-production.
Stage four production and post production work.
If you have a plan you have a chance of pulling it off.
If you just meander around nothing will be done.
With Adywan's projects their are about four threads losely or closely associated with them (some cross over to other projects too but on the whole they are energised by the Revisited versions).
ESB:R is still some time away and there is a lot of people working on providing ideas that Ady might use on not only ROTJ:R and the prequels and they are years away.
Those projects are based on films that have already been made once, the acting has been done, it been designed and filmed and still those projects are pulling out ideas only some of which will actually be realised by anyone not just Adywan.
Here there is one thread devoted to a project where nothing exists yet (which can be liberating but can also be very devisive).
If this thread begins to dry up put it on the back burner for a bit and just write the thing and come back with something concrete that people can add to and illustrate with pictures and the like.
But if you chaps are serious about getting this done don't give up.
"Do or do not, there is no try"