logo Sign In

Post #345167

Author
Vaderisnothayden
Parent topic
Star Wars and Indiana Jones on Blu-Ray Discussion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/345167/action/topic#345167
Date created
11-Feb-2009, 12:12 PM
C3PX said:

It is not bullshit to claim the PT was made to be seen after the original trilogy. It is pure fact that they were made to be seen before the original trilogy.

The PT is made so it works (as much as it works at all) seen AFTER the original trilogy. The OT does not work so well seen after the PT and was NOT made to be seen after the PT (despite claims to the contrary). The PT is very much made to be appreciated with full knowledge of the OT and thus seen after the OT. Despite claims to the contrary.

C3PX said:

George, who was the primary creative force behind the PT claims that they are meant to be seen before the others. His intention was to make them all fit together as a series to be seen chronologically.  

 

I'm not in the habit of believing George Lucas. It's possible he has convinced himself that the PT was made to be seen before the OT, but what he actually made is a trilogy designed to be seen after the OT. And the OT was certainly not designed to be seen after the PT, let alone THAT PT.