Darth Godbold said:thats not actually what im gonna call it...
maybe some one can help me out, work together on a title and crawl maybe.
eventually i will need a cover for the dvd aswell.
but first give it a view and let me know what you guys think
i cant say why my version stands out id say its like phantom editors version
with a few changes of my own it runs about 5 mins shorter than his version
i have also completely removed any mention of midichlorians and now anakin doesnt accidently
blow up the droid control ship i also removed a scene with his mother and put in part of a deleted scene theres a few changes to audio aswell no droids speak except when adressing a human or alien.
what i want to do is somehow darken the emporers hologram so its less obvious
that it is palpatine.
I don't mean to tread on your toes and I'm still downloading it but this sort of edit has been done many times before Slumberland/ADM/MagnoliaFan and TPE all have some if not all of what you describe plus had a different angle to add.
The Radical Redux Thread ideas are a bit more...radical than even that, turning Naboo into Alderaan for example completely changes the prequels.
Don't worry I'm still going to watch it but take a look out there and see what the other editors have been up to.
The Phantom Menace must be the most edited film out there for yours to stand out it has to do something that hasn't already done or do those things in ways which are much better than the people who have already attempted them.
Off the top of my head MagnoliaFan already darkened the hologram for his Balance Of The Force, if you like the way he did that I'm sure if you gave him credit for his work you could pinch that element of his edit.
After all we are all tinkering with George Lucas' work (something he does himself).