logo Sign In

Post #343202

Author
doubleofive
Parent topic
The Clone Wars (2008 animated tv series) - a general discussion thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/343202/action/topic#343202
Date created
26-Jan-2009, 3:52 PM
Karyudo said:
doubleofive said:

The episodes are 16:9 (HDTV ratio) originally, not 2:35:1 (film ratio).

I respectfully disagree. I compared screen caps, and the opening of the Sky HD version shows all the stars that CN shows (i.e. full height), plus more on both sides. I sincerely doubt the creators would make a 2.35:1 opening starfield for release to British TV, and then crop the show itself. It's probably possible to confirm this by comparing some shots from the show -- something I might do tonight.

Just because I'm that big a nerd, yo.

 

So the 16:9 letterbox on the SD channel is actually CROPPED from a 2:35:1 HD master?  That would be weird.  Maybe my CNHD is the same way, but I swear they were really long in the face.

I just checked the Cartoon Network website, and their full episodes are shown in 16:9:

The DVD of episodes that is coming out has them listed as being 16:9 also.

I have a theory.  Maybe the opening starfield on Sky is from the movie which was 2.35:1.  Then the rest in stretched.  I'll have to DVR and compare again, but with pictures (am I nerdy enough to take photos of my TV?  Yes, I am.)

It will be interesting to compare shots from the CN SD, CN HD, and SkyHD.  When does TNT start showing them?  I have them in SD and HD also.