ABC said:
Hi, I missed that thread by asking a suggestion on an other one...

Indeed I wanted to know wich ones between the Phantom and the Magnolia edits were worth to see. Wich are the best please ?

;)

Completely different approaches. The phantom editor simply cuts down the film to tell George's story in a quicker, more enjoyable pace with some of the prequel silliness removed. Magnoliafan does more of a complete overhaul with new alien voices. I don't like it too much but you might.