Like I said in my other thread, the usual ROTJ criticisms don't bother me either, but I still find it inferior. Even when I first saw it as a kid, it just didn't have the spark the other two did. Star Wars was amazing and exciting, Empire built up the excitement even more... and ROTJ just felt like an obligation to find out what happened at the end. It wasn't bad by any stretch of the imagination, but it just didn't provide the same emotional kick in the pants the others did. A total of about half an hour of the movie did, but the rest just sorta fell flat, especially after Empire brought things up to such a high level.