logo Sign In

Post #340418

Author
adywan
Parent topic
Rank the Star Wars films
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/340418/action/topic#340418
Date created
23-Dec-2008, 8:23 AM

1. The Empire Strikes back ( A masterpiece)
2. Star Wars (total classic)
3. Return of the Jedi (the signs of the long slide down to the prequels)
4. Attack of the clones (the only PT movie the whole family enjoyed at the cinema but many cringe worthy moments)
5. Revenge of the Sith ( Total disappointment with everything being wrapped up in a rush at the end and the kids fell asleep half way through which was not a good sign)
6. The Phantom menace (the only Star Wars film i have ever walked out of the cinema speechless and depressed. Haven't been able to watch again since its DVD release. )

AxiaEuxine said:

If we are talking about Star Wars then yes, I love the original editions. I also love the special editions and some fan edits, In fact I just got done watching SW revisted. what a mastepiece. It only makes me sad that he hates the prequels .

I have said many times that i don't hate the PT. Just because i rank them well below the OT doesn't mean i hate them (well apart from TPM). I just can't believe that you placed ROTS at number 1 above any of the OT. Are you serious or was that just to stir up some trouble because you don't like anyone that bashes your beloved PT? That film is garbage compared to ANH & ESB. Its worrying, and saddening,  when i see when some Star Wars fans rate the originals lower than the PT.