C3PX said:
Octorox said:
C3PX said:
Octorox said:
Why exactly are you re-dubbing Owen and Lama Su? Did you just not like the original voices?

New lines.

What does he have planned? the phantom editor was able to fix their lines really well without redubbing. Unless you plan to eliminate the whole Sifo Diyas thing. Owens are fine though. Phantom Editor was able to remove the whole "stepbrother" thing.

This is a very different kind of edit from that of the Phantom Editor's. Trooperman really made some very large changes throughout the movie. Sometimes redubbing characters was the best way to change the plot at some points or to cover up wholes left by deleted scenes.

Your best bet to understanding the spirit of this edit would be to go back and read page one.

Oh I know it's a far more drastic edit. I'm just saying that I'm not sure exactly what could be achieved by redubbing Owen. Any weak lines can really be edited out as the phantom editor did and Owen doesn't have enough screen time to really add anything to the story with a redub IMO. btw has anyone thought about turning Geonosis into Tatooine and Naboo into Alderaan? I'd like to see a full-scale battle on Tatooine