Trooperman said:
I remember reading an article where it stated that most professional cinematographers were "appalled" at how bad AOTC looked in theaters (due to the still-new HD filming). The colors are so screwed up, and combined with all the phony looking digital effects it looks like a cartoon.

Word. That's part of the reason I like the Silent Film version of the saga, as it sort of "hides" a lot of the insane CGness that is apparent at times in the prequels, and removes the cartoonishness of the color, of course.