i would love to see windu go alone, this would remove the crappy jedi deaths, plus make it seem a bit more dramamtic (he is going to take ALONE?!)

I don't think so. Acting so spountainiously wasn't wise at most, going there alone would be just plain stupid.

but if we see anakin turn into vader, where is the surprise for ESB? i back ady for this.

Oh sure, apart from Anakin turning into Vader, there is absolutely no indication that Vader could possibly be Luke's father.

Btw, it's a bit sarcastic tone, no offence ment, mate.

Oh, and I've read AxiaEuxine's blog. While I do not fully agree with that editorial, I do think she (he? O_o) has some points. That's from a point of view of a guy who got accomodated with SW with EpI, in 1999, while he was just an 8-years old boy. I have my share of complaints, yes, but I do think that PT does something better than OT (and not only graphically-wise) and OT does something better than PT. But nevertheless, it's still one big saga.

Oh, and yeah. I don't like contradictions very much. But remember the greeks. They didn't have absolutely anything against contradictions in their mythology :p On the contray, some suppose they thought contradictions were necessary. Still would be glad if the contradictions in SW would be reduced to a minimum.