but if we see anakin turn into vader, where is the surprise for ESB? i back ady for this.

just a note for palpatine vs mace windu fight:

i would love to see windu go alone, this would remove the crappy jedi deaths, plus make it seem a bit more dramamtic (he is going to take him ALONE?!)

also, maybe enstead of anakin pleading for windu to not kill sidious, ie:

windu "i am going to end this once and for all!"

sidious "no dont!"

anakin "i need him"

anakin attacks windu

the dialogue could run:

windu hols off lightening, almost overcome

windu: "anakin, help me, end this!"

anakin ponders

anakin (COLDLY) "no."

anakin attacks windu (or maybe kills him?)

it would make his decision seem less passive, and maybe like he had decided before even entering the room. the "no" would be almost like when ISILDUR decides to keep the ring in Fellowship of the Ring, kind of callous and evil.

if vader isnt to feature as such, making anakins sabre red for the end fight would probably make the vader-skywalker link to obvious, so blue would fit better. it would be cool if we are left feeling like "anakin almost became a sith lord, thank god obi killed him before he got his red sabre"

the yoda - sidious fight, if it isnt removed ( i REALLY hated it) would be amazing if it is more like the wizards battle in harry potter V between voldemort and dumbledore, just lightening of two colours destroying everything around them. it would be neat having yoda never use his sabre (except when he beheads the clone troopers as ady said)