AxiaEuxine said:
I disagree with this. I love A New Hope revisited and cant wait for Empire, but Im afraid Adywan will do what every fan edit of any prequel movie has done and that is to completely gut them becuase the editor didnt like anything about the prequels in the first place. I hope this isnt the case.

I say leave Threepio in.

I know the midiclorians are gonna be taken out but how do you leave the Opera scene between Palpatine and Anakin intact without them?

well thats probably because they need gutting to tone down the horrible script and wooden acting. Things are explained way too much in the PT. The whole script talks down to the audience. The editing is a mess and is nowhere near as tight as it was in the OT. Just look how long they linger on a scene before either a wipe or a cut. And 3PO is just there for no other reason apart from GL fanwank. He does nothing and Anthony Daniels performance in the PT was more of a caricature of 3PO than the 3PO we loved in the PT. In the OT 3POn was annoying but funny. In the PT he was just pain annoying and i cringed every time he spoke. Just listen to all the "ooh" "ahh" Ughh's" he adds between almost every line. Since when did 3PO do that? Even in the Clone Wars tv series he doesn't do that. 3PO really doesn't need to be in the PT at all but ROTS was the better place to have him make an appearance as Padmes servant droid. The opera scene can easily be kept without the inclusion of midicraplions ever mentioned in the PT. It's all down to editing. And the hint that Anakin was created by the sith and the miracle Virgin birth will also be gone in Revisited. The PT needs to be given a complete make over whereas the OT is mainly cosmetics.