Johnboy3434 said:

Besides, who says he ruined Star Wars to being with?

I can only answer this for myself, as he has ruined the OOT for me, simply because I can't watch the damn movies in any good quality anymore.

It has nothing to do with the PT, EU, Clone War stuff, simply I cannot watch the OOT on DVD the same way I watch Raiders, Jaws, Superman, Back to the Future, all movies I grew up and loved. None of my feelings have changed for those movies and they all have inferior sequels, yet they have great quality DVD's. Now if I want to watch the OOT now, I pop in a grainy, blurry, shitty DVD, the GOUT, that is an insult to any fan who has an HDTV.

So essentially he may not have ruined SW in a general sense, but he ruined it for fans like me, but isn't that just as bad?